Not every ingredient on a toothpaste label is a reason to put the tube back. The main ones worth checking are ingredients that may irritate the mouth, increase abrasion or have raised regulatory concerns.

So which toothpaste ingredients are worth checking?

Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (SLS), for example, may aggravate recurrent mouth ulcers. Highly abrasive whitening formulas may be unsuitable for people with exposed dentine, enamel wear or sensitivity. Titanium dioxide and diethanolamine have also drawn regulatory scrutiny.

Fluoride and approved sweeteners are different. At the concentrations used in toothpaste, the evidence does not support automatically treating them as harmful ingredients.

Ingredients Linked to Mouth Irritation

For people with sensitive oral tissue, certain toothpaste ingredients can trigger or worsen irritation without harming everyone else who uses them.

1. Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (SLS)

Sodium Lauryl Sulfate is an anionic surfactant that helps toothpaste spread and foam during brushing.

  • The concern: SLS can irritate oral tissue in some people, particularly those prone to recurrent canker sores.
  • What the research shows: A systematic review found that SLS-free toothpaste reduced ulcer number, duration, episodes and pain in people with recurrent aphthous ulcers.
  • Who may want to avoid it: People who regularly experience canker sores or irritation from conventional foaming toothpaste. On ingredient lists, SLS may also appear as Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate.

Pearlie White toothpastes are formulated without SLS, making them an option for people who prefer an SLS-free formula.

2. Activated Charcoal and High-Abrasivity Additives

Abrasives help toothpaste remove plaque and surface stains. Some whitening toothpastes also use activated charcoal, but its whitening benefits and abrasivity vary by formulation.

  • The concern: Excessive abrasion can contribute to dentine wear, particularly where dentine is already exposed, or teeth are sensitive.
  • What the research shows: Evidence supporting charcoal toothpaste for whitening is limited, while studies have found substantial differences in abrasivity between charcoal products.
  • Who may want to be cautious: People with exposed dentine, enamel erosion or sensitivity should pay closer attention to how abrasive a whitening toothpaste is.

RDA tells you how abrasive a toothpaste is on dentine, the softer layer beneath your tooth enamel. It is useful information, but it should not be the only factor when choosing a toothpaste. More abrasive toothpastes may help remove stubborn surface stains, but they are not necessarily better at removing plaque. A gentler formula may be preferable if you have sensitive or worn teeth, or exposed dentine. 

If you are unsure, ask your dentist which toothpaste best suits your needs. 

3. Artificial Colours and Synthetic Sweeteners

Artificial colours are added for appearance, while sweeteners improve the taste of toothpaste without using ordinary sugar. Neither group is an active ingredient for preventing tooth decay.

  • The concern: Certain colourants can trigger hypersensitivity reactions in susceptible people. Sweeteners such as saccharin and aspartame are also frequently included on ingredient warning lists.
  • What the research shows: Older animal studies raised concerns about saccharin, but these have not been confirmed as a cancer risk in humans. Regulatory bodies continue to consider approved sweeteners safe within established intake limits.
  • Who may want to avoid them: People with a known sensitivity to a particular colourant or sweetener can check the ingredient list and choose a formula without it.

Ingredients That Regulatory Bodies Have Restricted or Are Reviewing

The next group is different. These are among the bad ingredients in toothpaste that regulators have restricted or are actively reviewing, usually over concerns that reach beyond the mouth.

4. Triclosan

Triclosan is an antibacterial ingredient used in toothpaste to help control plaque and gingivitis.

  • The concern: Triclosan has been investigated for potential endocrine effects and its possible contribution to antimicrobial resistance.
  • What the research and regulators say: The US FDA removed triclosan from certain over-the-counter antiseptic hand washes in 2016 because manufacturers had not provided enough evidence to support those uses. That ruling did not ban triclosan in toothpaste. The EU Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety later concluded that triclosan at 0.3% in toothpaste is safe when used on its own for adults and children aged 6 months and above, although combined exposure from several triclosan-containing products raised concerns for children under 3.
  • Who may want to avoid it: Anyone who prefers to minimise exposure to antibacterial ingredients can check the label for triclosan, particularly when using several personal-care products that contain it.

5. Parabens

Parabens are preservatives used to stop bacteria and fungi from growing in cosmetic and personal-care products.

  • The concern: Some parabens have shown potential endocrine activity, leading regulators to assess different members of the paraben family separately.
  • What the research and regulators say: The EU has banned several parabens, including isopropylparaben and isobutylparaben. Propylparaben and butylparaben remain permitted at restricted concentrations. The SCCS currently considers each safe as a cosmetic preservative at concentrations up to 0.14%, although limits and age-specific exposure remain under review.
  • Who may want to avoid them: People who prefer paraben-free products can check the ingredient list, but permitted parabens should not be described as proven harmful at the concentrations regulators currently allow.

6. Titanium Dioxide

Titanium dioxide (TiO₂) is a white pigment used to give toothpaste an opaque, bright-white appearance. It does not provide an oral-health benefit.

  • The concern: Scientific reviews have raised questions about whether certain titanium dioxide particles could damage genetic material after exposure.
  • What the research and regulators say: EFSA concluded in 2021 that titanium dioxide could no longer be considered safe as the food additive E171 because genotoxicity could not be ruled out. Toothpaste is assessed separately because it is not intended to be swallowed. In 2024, however, the EU SCCS found that the available evidence was still insufficient to exclude genotoxic potential for almost all titanium dioxide grades assessed for oral cosmetics and called for further research.
  • Who may want to avoid it: Anyone taking a precautionary approach can choose a titanium-dioxide-free toothpaste. This may be particularly relevant when selecting products for young children who are more likely to swallow some toothpaste.

Common Additives With More Limited or Contested Evidence

Propylene glycol and diethanolamine are both regularly included on lists of toothpaste ingredients to avoid, but they should not be treated the same way. Propylene glycol has a low toxicity profile at normal consumer exposure, while DEA has tighter restrictions because of concerns around nitrosamine formation.

7. Propylene Glycol

Propylene glycol is a solvent and humectant used to retain moisture and help ingredients remain evenly dispersed in a formulation.

  • The concern: High systemic exposure to propylene glycol has been associated with effects such as hyperosmolality and metabolic acidosis. It can also cause irritation or allergic contact reactions in a small number of people.
  • What the research says: The metabolic effects reported in medical literature involve exposure far above what would be expected from normal toothpaste use. Toxicological reviews describe propylene glycol as having a very low overall risk to human health, although irritation and uncommon contact allergy can occur.
  • Who may want to avoid it: People with a confirmed propylene glycol allergy or who repeatedly experience irritation from products containing it may prefer a propylene-glycol-free formula.

For most people, current evidence does not support classifying propylene glycol in toothpaste as harmful.

8. Diethanolamine (DEA)

Diethanolamine, or DEA, is an alkanolamine used in personal-care formulations to adjust pH and in DEA-related ingredients that act as emulsifiers or foaming agents.

  • The concern: DEA can contribute to the formation of N-nitrosamines under certain formulation conditions. Some nitrosamines are carcinogenic, which is why regulators place controls on DEA and related compounds.
  • What the research and regulators say: European scientific committees have recommended that secondary alkanolamines such as DEA not be used in cosmetics because they can form nitrosamines. In the US, the FDA notes that animal studies found an association between topical DEA exposure and cancer, but did not establish a link with cancer in humans.
  • Who may want to avoid it: Anyone taking a precautionary approach can check the label for DEA and DEA-related ingredients, particularly Cocamide DEA and Lauramide DEA.

DEA therefore has a stronger regulatory basis for caution than propylene glycol, although the FDA does not currently advise consumers that DEA-containing cosmetics present a proven human cancer risk.

Is Fluoride a Harmful Ingredient in Toothpaste?

Fluoride is not considered a harmful toothpaste ingredient when used as directed. It has strong clinical evidence for preventing tooth decay, and the World Health Organization recommends twice-daily brushing with toothpaste containing 1,000 to 1,500 ppm fluoride. Locally, Singapore's National Dental Centre also encourages fluoride use for everyone, including children as soon as their teeth start emerging.

A Cochrane review found that fluoride toothpaste reduces tooth decay compared with non-fluoride toothpaste. In children and adolescents, toothpastes containing 1,000 to 1,250 ppm and 1,450 to 1,500 ppm fluoride both reduced new decay, with some evidence of a greater effect at the higher concentration.

For young children, the main concern is swallowing too much fluoride while the teeth are developing, which can contribute to dental fluorosis. The amount of toothpaste used should therefore be controlled:

  • Under 3 years: Use a smear or rice-grain-sized amount.
  • Ages 3 to 6: Use a pea-sized amount.
  • Young children: Supervise brushing and encourage them to spit out the toothpaste.

Fluoride vs Hydroxyapatite: What Is the Difference?

Both fluoride and hydroxyapatite support enamel, but they work differently and have different levels of clinical evidence.

Feature

Fluoride

Hydroxyapatite

What it does

Reduces enamel demineralisation and promotes remineralisation after acid exposure

Deposits mineral particles onto enamel and can fill small surface defects

Caries evidence

Large body of long-term clinical evidence

Growing clinical evidence, but substantially fewer trials

Typical use

Standard anti-caries active in everyday toothpaste

Fluoride-free remineralising active

Main safety consideration

Control swallowing in young children

No fluoride-related fluorosis concern

Best suited for

People seeking established fluoride-based cavity prevention

People specifically seeking a fluoride-free remineralising formula

How Fluoride Protects Enamel

Fluoride works mainly at the tooth surface.

  • How it works: It reduces mineral loss when acids attack enamel and promotes the return of calcium and phosphate as oral conditions recover.
  • Why it is used: The remineralised enamel becomes more resistant to future acid attacks.
  • What the research shows: Fluoride toothpaste has decades of clinical evidence supporting its role in reducing tooth decay.

How Hydroxyapatite Works

Hydroxyapatite is the main mineral component of tooth enamel.

  • How it works: Hydroxyapatite particles deposit on the tooth surface and can fill microscopic enamel irregularities.
  • Why it is used: It supports remineralisation without fluoride, making it an option for people specifically looking for a fluoride-free active ingredient.
  • What the research shows: Clinical evidence is growing. A 2025 systematic review found no significant difference between hydroxyapatite and fluoride toothpastes in the development or progression of initial caries lesions across the four eligible studies, although the evidence base remains much smaller than fluoride’s.

Pearlie White Optimal A.R.T. Active Remineralization Toothpaste is fluoride-free and uses hydroxyapatite as its remineralising ingredient, alongside xylitol and CPC.

Which Toothpaste Ingredients Are Worth Looking For?

Some toothpaste ingredients prevent decay, reduce sensitivity or support gum and breath care. The most useful one depends on what you need the toothpaste to do.

Ingredient

What it is used for

What the evidence supports

Fluoride, usually 1,000–1,500 ppm

Preventing tooth decay and supporting remineralisation

Strong clinical evidence for reducing caries

Hydroxyapatite

Supporting enamel remineralisation

Growing clinical evidence, although there are fewer long-term studies than for fluoride

Potassium nitrate / potassium salts

Reducing dentine sensitivity

Clinical evidence supports several potassium-based desensitising formulations

Xylitol

Non-cariogenic sweetening and oral-care support

Can reduce levels of mutans streptococci, although evidence for preventing caries on its own is mixed

Zinc salts

Managing bad breath

Can reduce volatile sulphur compounds linked to oral malodour

CPC (Cetylpyridinium Chloride)

Helping control plaque-related bacteria

Research supports a modest additional reduction in plaque and gingival inflammation when used alongside brushing

For mouth rinses and gum care products, ingredients such as CPC and zinc may also be useful depending on the product and its intended purpose.

What Should You Check Before You Buy Toothpaste?

No single toothpaste formula suits everyone. Check the active ingredients first, then look for anything that may irritate your mouth or not suit your dental needs.

  • If you often get canker sores: Look for an SLS-free toothpaste.
  • If you have sensitive teeth or exposed dentine: Check whether the toothpaste is designed for sensitivity and avoid choosing a whitening product solely for its abrasive action.
  • If you want established cavity protection: Look for fluoride at an appropriate concentration.
  • If you prefer a fluoride-free formula: Hydroxyapatite is one alternative with growing clinical evidence.
  • If you are cautious about ingredients under regulatory review: Check the label for ingredients such as titanium dioxide or DEA.
  • If you have a known allergy or sensitivity: Avoid the specific ingredient responsible instead of assuming every synthetic ingredient is harmful.

Pearlie White toothpastes are formulated without SLS, Titanium Dioxide, DEA, Propylene Glycol, and Parabens, while our mouthwashes are alcohol-free. For those looking for a fluoride-free option, Optimal A.R.T. Active Remineralization Toothpaste uses hydroxyapatite as its remineralising ingredient. Shop Pearlie White toothpastes, mouth rinses and other gum care products to find a formula that suits your oral care routine.